adminpack.pub About

Tool · Recommended

Gusto

Payroll, payroll taxes, contractor payments and benefits for small US teams. Choose the plan by how many states you pay in.

Cost: Simple: $49 per month plus $6 per person per month; one state All cost facts
Jump to a section

Verdict

Gusto is the payroll service I recommend for small US publishers. It files payroll taxes, pays employees and contractors, and posts payroll to QuickBooks. Choose the plan by the number of states you pay in, and count add-ons such as state registration before comparing totals.

At a glance

Good fit for
  • US publishers with a few to a few dozen employees, contractors or both.
  • Teams paying people in more than one state (Plus or Premium).
  • Organizations that want an approval step before each payroll and a clean journal entry in QuickBooks.
Choose something else if
  • Publishers whose staff are all outside the US.
  • Organizations that already have payroll bundled with a professional employer organization (PEO) or benefits provider they want to keep.
  • A solo publisher paying only themselves through owner draws, who may not need payroll at all; ask your accountant.
Experience behind this
Used in practice. I use it to run payroll at two nonprofit newsrooms I help run.
Provider
Gusto, Inc. · Official site (external)

Why it earns a place

Gusto is the payroll service I use and recommend for small US publishers. It pays employees and contractors, files and pays payroll taxes, handles new-hire paperwork, and posts each payroll to QuickBooks Online. The plan choice is mostly about geography: Simple covers one state, and paying anyone in a second state means Plus or Premium. I found no nonprofit rate on Gusto’s pricing page.

Where it fits

It fits a publisher with a handful to a few dozen people, including freelancers paid as contractors. It is a good match when you want a second person to approve payroll and a bookkeeper to receive a clean journal entry. It is less useful if your benefits provider already includes payroll you want to keep, or if your team is outside the US.

Classify people correctly before the first payroll. Whether a regular contributor is an employee or a contractor is a legal question, not a payroll setting, and the answer changes taxes, filings and benefits. Ask your accountant or employment counsel when in doubt; Gusto pays people as you set them up.

A working setup

  1. Payroll administrator (often the operations or finance lead) sets up the company, bank account, tax registrations and pay schedule, and connects QuickBooks Online.
  2. Each new hire completes onboarding in Gusto: tax forms, direct deposit and documents. Contractors add their payment and tax details.
  3. Payroll administrator enters changes before each run: new hires, departures, raises, reimbursements and contractor invoices.
  4. Approver (the executive director or treasurer, per the financial manual) reviews the payroll preview and approves before the cut-off. The administrator and approver should be different people where staffing allows.
  5. Gusto pays staff and remits taxes; the journal entry posts to QuickBooks.
  6. Bookkeeper reconciles payroll expense, clearing and liability accounts at month-end.
  7. Payroll administrator reviews W-2s and 1099s in January before they are filed.

What it costs

The cost facts table below lists the current base and per-person prices. For domestic payroll, total monthly cost is the base fee plus the applicable per-person fees and add-ons. Global contractor payments have separate fee terms in the cost facts. A ten-person team paid in one state on Simple pays the base plus ten per-person fees; adding an employee in a second state moves you to Plus and adds a state registration add-on. Benefits integrations and 401(k) providers carry their own fees.

Living with it

Gusto is US payroll. Paying people abroad needs the international contractor add-on or another service. New states take paperwork and an add-on fee. Retirement plans connected through Gusto are priced by the plan provider, so compare the provider’s fees separately. Upkeep is the rhythm of each pay period: changes in on time, approval before cut-off, and a monthly reconciliation of payroll liabilities.

Change providers at a quarter boundary, preferably the start of the calendar year, so tax filings are not split across two services. Download registers, filings and year-end forms first, and confirm the new provider has accurate year-to-date totals.

Cost facts

ItemPublished termsSource and check date
Simple$49 per month plus $6 per person per month; one state
Plus$80 per month plus $12 per person per month; multi-state
Premium$180 per month plus $22 per person per month
Global contractor paymentsAdd-on with no monthly per-contractor fee; foreign exchange rates vary; $5 per payment to US-based bank accounts
State tax registrationAdd-on on all plans; pricing varies by state
Health insurance broker integration$6 per month per eligible employee

Count employees and domestic contractors when estimating payroll per-person fees. The Global contractor payments add-on has its own fee terms in the cost facts. Add-ons such as state registration, faster pay timing on Simple, and benefit integrations add to the base. Gusto states it charges no setup fee and has no contract; the internal cost is a payroll administrator and an approver each pay period.

Prices change. These are the provider's published terms on the dates shown, not a quote.

Quick reference

Limitations
  • US payroll only; international contractors are an add-on.
  • Simple covers one state; multi-state payroll needs Plus or Premium.
  • Registering in a new state is an extra, state-priced add-on.
  • Retirement plan pricing and features depend on the provider you connect.
Ongoing work
  • Payroll administrator prepares each payroll and attaches changes.
  • Approver reviews and approves before the cut-off.
  • Bookkeeper reconciles payroll clearing and liability accounts monthly.
  • Year-end W-2 and 1099 review.
Connects with
  • QuickBooks Online payroll journal entries
  • Health insurance brokers and carriers
  • 401(k) providers (pricing varies by provider)
  • Time tracking (Plus and Premium)
Leaving
Switch providers at a quarter boundary if you can, ideally January 1, so quarterly and annual tax filings are not split. Download payroll registers, tax filings, W-2s and 1099s before leaving, and confirm the new provider has year-to-date figures for every employee.
Alternatives
  • Your accounting software's payroll add-on: Keeps payroll in the ledger, but data may not move if you later change accounting subscriptions.
  • A PEO: Bundles payroll with co-employment benefits; can make sense when access to group health plans is the main need.
  • A payroll service through your bank or accountant: Some bookkeeping firms run payroll as part of their service.

Sources

  1. Gusto pricing, plans and fees, Gusto. Checked October 14, 2026. Supports: Simple is $49 per month plus $6 per month per person and runs basic payroll in one state. Plus is $80 per month plus $12 per month per person and includes multi-state payroll, time tracking and next-day pay. Premium is $180 per month plus $22 per month per person and includes same-day and instant pay and HR tools. All plans include unlimited payrolls, tax filings and payments, payroll approvals and domestic contractor payments. State tax registration is an add-on on every plan, priced by state. Global contractor payments are an add-on with no monthly per-contractor fee; foreign exchange rates vary and payments to US-based bank accounts cost $5 each. Gusto states there are no contracts and account setup is free. Health insurance broker integration is $6 per month per eligible employee; 401(k) pricing varies by integration.

By Jonathan Keen. Content updated November 11, 2026 · first published October 14, 2026.

Disclosure: No commercial relationship: AdminPack receives nothing from the companies named on this page. Links are ordinary links. See the editorial policy.

Something out of date? Suggest a correction. Know a tool or program I should cover? Suggest a tool or program.